-Thou-Hadst-Been-Damned

Abstinence

Agony

Ashes

Barzillai

Divine-Authority

Fear

Fight-the-Good-Fight-of-Faith

Flee-fornication

Forsaken

Godlye

Handmaid

Hate-bad

Hate-evil

Hearsay

Helpless

Humiliation

One Puritan virtue name unlikely to thrive in the 21st century.

Increase

If-Jesus-Christ-Had-Not-Died-For-Thee-

Jesus-Christ-Came-Into-The-World-To-Save

Job-Raked-Out-Of-The-Ashes

Joy-In-Sorrow

Judas-Not-Iscariot

Kill-sin

Lament

Lechery

Mehetabell

More-Fruit

Moreover

My-Sake

No-Merit

It may have been used by the Puritans, but any modern child would chafe under this name. 

Obedience

In the trending royal names class, Pharaoh is one of the rarer entries. Pharaoh is the title of the ancient Egypitan rulers.
</br></br>
Famous jazz saxophonist Pharoah [sic] Saunders was really named Ferrell. 

Pharaoh

Pardon

Persecution

Praise-God

Pride

Rediviva

Repent

Revolt

Riches

Sabbath

Search-the-scriptures

Sin-deny

Sorry-for-sin

Submit

Tell-no

Weakly

Wrath

Wrestling

Zaphnaphpaaneah

Zeal-for-God

ultracrepidarian's list "Favorite Puritan Names" of 52 great name ideas: -Thou-Hadst-Been-Damned - Zeal-for-God!

Favorite Puritan Names

Supposedly Puritans sometimes chose a random word from the Bible to use for their children's names. That would explain some of their more...interesting choices.
You just can't make this up.